Notes

Here you can view all the lovely things people had to say about the featured whiskeys and also view pictures that they have submitted.

Matt Eagle

Precious

Very enjoyable! Is this Suntory? Super light golden color, fruity profile with grapefruit and a bit of a bite at the end. Overall, very drinkable. Interested to see how split the numbers are on this one.

Josh Mitchell

Full Body

I spilled a little bit of this pouring it into my glass, and I could not be more upset. This is everything I want in a whisky. Hang on, I gotta go lick my kitchen counter.

Allan Maule

PPP

Light touch, and I appreciate the graceful citrus of this one.

Ben Freeman

Wildcard

No idea what this is, but its "mid" as my kids would say...

Jonathan Cory Kraftchick

Hef

A little low proof for my taste, but the flavor is pretty good. 🍌🍌🍌🍌🍌

James Hatfield

Hanky

Seems clean and easy to drink. I like it.

Josh Mitchell

Full Body

What is this? It's weird in a bad way.

Mark Peters

Shaft

Favorite of day 2-8, for sure. Initially, I got a lot of alcohol, but it mellowed nicely and got better and better with each subsequent sip. I wish I had more.

James Hopkins

Tubs

Uneven floral smoke—Forest things that come to mine.

Derek Glunz

Quotes

Perfectly acceptable but I wouldn’t choose to drink this. It is a mixer. If you made it into a rusty nail, it might be passable.

Allan Maule

PPP

Unusual flavor profile! This mixes sweet corn with pepper. Wondering if this is the local bottle I picked.

Matt Eagle

Precious

Well, this is interesting. Tastes like a bourbon. The flavors are nicely layered with some spice at the end. Enjoyable in an unexpected way, so I’d understand if some folks don’t love it.

John McDowell

Worm

Love the flavor profile but seems too light/faint. Would like a little more pop. Rye? Japanese? Japanese rye?

Jonathan Cory Kraftchick

Hef

I didn't love it, didn't hate it. Not sure I'd but this again, but if someone bought me a bottle, I'd still say thank you.

Ben Freeman

Wildcard

very light color - thought it was Irish until I gave it a whiff. It smells like if you mixed Four Roses and Sake together. Taste notes to me are honey/floral/vanilla. Not a very high ABV. Let it sit out a bit in the glass, and it changed. At first sip...hated it. After a while, it grew on me. Would buy

Derek Glunz

Quotes

Smooth, gentle as an eastern breeze in a Chicago summer

James Hopkins

Tubs

Really Good.

Josh Mitchell

Full Body

So nice. Smooth and easy.

John McDowell

Worm

So smooth- hope this is one of my choices. The proof with scotch is always higher than it seems for me, tastes like a highland or speyside one

James Hatfield

Hanky

I think I know this scotch from the nose. Smells like a seagulls armpit and taste like an oil slick. And it’s delicious.

Matt Eagle

Precious

Hello scotch! This is very pleasant and very drinkable. I’d suspect this would be approachable for novice scotch drinkers. If I’m being super nit picky, I want there to be a bit more body and interest in the flavor profile, but it’s inoffensive in every way.

Allan Maule

PPP

Has the citrus and honey notes of a young MaCallan or Glenmorangie. Tasty, but unremarkable.

Mark Peters

Shaft

I want to like peaty scotches, I really do....I just don't.

Ben Freeman

Wildcard

Didn't like it at first, but after letting it open a little, really liked it. Little too much ethanol that lasts.

Prev Next